Rings are nicely made. Although the rings look cylindrical in the photo they are actually more like a large wedding band. Flatter on the inside next to the rod and rounder on the outside. I think the shape makes them look even better than the photo shows. One minor point. The description should state that these rings are polished AND clear coated. For those who want to antique the rings or have them darken naturally over time, it is necessary to remove the coating. Great product and great service.