I would have rated this a five, except it kind of ticks me off that they are now even cheaper. Plus, the shipping was kind of high. The product itself was good, though.
Like many folks, the old table with turned legs we have is too short. Its solid, but you really can hardly get your legs under it using a wooden kitchen table or worse, castors. These fit the bill perfectly .. nicely marked center hole spots, solid oak (though of the 4 I bought one is laminated in 9 pieces). The wood took the stain nicely, and you are given the choice of the size of footprint you want on the floor. I used a pretty fancy mounting system I bought at the local Ace Hardware that allows for metal dowels/screws to hold it to the bottom of the leg (and can be removed if necessary). My only beef is the cost after shipping is expensive. I'd have given a better rating if not for that.